GameHarbor

Think that Five Nights at Freddy's was the pinnacle of horror gaming? Think again.

If you're looking for more intense tension, creepy atmospheres, and mechanical monsters, you've come to the correct place. Whether you're seeking independent gems or want to download Roblox for horror-themed experiences, we've compiled a list of the creepiest games that will haunt your nightmares.

When Five Nights at Freddy's (FNaF) initially appeared on the game scene, it revolutionized horror with minimal action, maximum tension, and a terrible secret hidden behind flickering security cameras. And if you're still suffering from late nights trying to survive Freddy and the gang, we've found the perfect horrifying fix.

Here are some horror games similar to FNaF that will have you on edge and jumping at every creak in the dark.

What Is Five Nights at Freddy’s?

Five Nights at Freddy's (FNaF) debuted in 2014 and immediately became a horror gaming hit. You are the evening security guard at Freddy Fazbear's Pizza, a children's pizzeria haunted by murderous animatronics. With limited power, surveillance cameras, and sheer nerve, your mission is to survive five nights without being apprehended and scared to death.

What set FNaF apart was its unique approach—there is no running or fighting back. Instead, you sit in a small office with doors, lighting, and cameras to monitor the animatronics. The psychological tension, along with a strange and sinister narrative, transformed FNaF into a franchise, community, and genre-defining title.

If you like the thrill of monitoring gloomy passageways, saving power, and dreading every flicker of light, you'll adore the games on this list.

List of Horror Games Like FNaF

1. Bendy and the Ink Machine

Why it’s like FNaF:

Creepy individuals, unsettling environments, & a mystery that gradually reveals itself.

Vibe: Vintage cartoon horror with psychological twists.

In this unsettling first-person adventure, you explore an abandoned animation studio filled with inky dreams. Bendy and the Ink Machine, with its haunting graphics and slow-building dread, is a story-driven horror experience that is both mentally upsetting and horrifying.

2. Tattletail

Why it’s like FNaF:

Animatronic toys with unexpected behavior and alarming artificial intelligence.

Vibe: Childhood nostalgia turned into a living nightmare.

Remember the '90s talking toys? Consider one that welcomes something much more sinister into your home. As you care for your Tattletail, you must evade its terrible "Mama"—who is stalking you through your home. Sounds familiar? There is real tension.

3. CASE: Animatronics

Why it’s like FNaF:

Security cameras, flickering lights, and murderous robots.

Vibe: Police-station horror meets killer machines.

You play as a detective locked in a gloomy, strangely silent police station. Are these the only things that move? Animatronics stalk you through the halls. This realistic, FNaF-inspired experience includes a tablet for monitoring camera feeds and unlocking doors, with the added freedom to wander around if desired.

4. Dark Deception

Why it’s like FNaF:

Heart-pounding horror with terrifying chases and creepy mascots.

Vibe: Pac-Man, but from your worst nightmares.

Instead of sitting motionless, Dark Deception transports you to a maze in which wicked cartoon mascots constantly pursue you. It's a unique take on survival horror, with fast-paced gameplay and unnerving imagery that conveys the ever-present sense of dread that FNaF fans are familiar with.

5. The Joy of Creation: Story Mode

Why it’s like FNaF:

It is FNaF—just turned up to 100.

Vibe: Cinematic horror with free-roaming animatronics.

The Joy of Creation, a horrifying fan-made FNaF offshoot, enriches the lore while also introducing more dynamic gameplay. With new environments, mechanics, and truly terrifying animatronics, this game may even surpass the original in terms of raw, undiluted horror.

6. Emily Wants to Play

Why it’s like FNaF:

Jump scares, time-based survival, and dolls that move when you blink.

Vibe: You're the delivery guy, and you really should’ve left.

As a pizza delivery worker, you are locked within a spooky mansion with dolls that each have their own terrifying set of rules. Understanding your enemy's behavior, like FNaF, is critical to survival during the night.

Bonus: You'll never look at children's toys the same way.

7. Boogeyman

Why it’s like FNaF:

One room. One flashlight. One thing creeping in the shadows.

Vibe: Classic bedtime horror with a deadly twist.

In Boogeyman, you're trapped in your bedroom with only a flashlight to fight off a mysterious threat. You'll have to deal with batteries, sound cues, & your own anxiety as the beast comes closer each night. Similar to FNaF, every second feels like surviving by the skin of your teeth.

Bonus: Roblox Horror Experiences

Why it’s like FNaF:

Tons of user-made horror games inspired by animatronics, jump scares, and survival.

Vibe: Endless variety from creepy to straight-up nightmare fuel.

If you're going to download Roblox, don't skip the vast library of horror experiences. Titles such as Bear, Dead Silence, The Mimic, and Piggy offer unique shocks and community-driven material that is frequently inspired by or pays homage to FNaF. It is a horror feast for thrill seekers.

Final Thoughts

FNaF is more than simply a game; it's a mood. The quiet. The ticking clock. The fear of what is just beyond sight. These games build on that history, bringing their own take on suspense, strategy, and psychological terror.

Whether you're hiding from ghostly dolls, being stalked by animatronics, or crawling through ink-soaked halls, one thing is certain: you won't be sleeping tonight.

So turn off the lights (if you dare), put on your headphones, and prepare for some heart-pounding horror.

About the Author

Hey there! I am Jessica Davis, a game creator, computer geek, and gamer. I'm always looking for new games that push the boundaries of horror and storytelling, and I enjoy sharing my knowledge with other enthusiasts.

I hope you enjoyed learning about these scary FNaF-inspired games.

Please let me know what you think, and feel free to add your own favorites in the comments. Have fun gaming and remain creepy! 

Ref:

Jason, Z. (2025, April 2). The 38 Best Horror Games to Play with Your Friends. WikiHow. https://www.wikihow.com/Scary-Games-to-Play-with-Friends